Tech big guns confront U.K. parliament on backdoors, encryption

A group of high tech corporate powerhouses has gathered together to protest a law proposed by the U.K. government that would allow an array of legal and intelligence agencies the ability to access computer data through backdoors and decryption.

Facebook, Google, Microsoft, Twitter and Yahoo submitted a letter, dated December 21, 2015, to the parliamentary committee charged with reviewing the Investigatory Powers Bill saying it would have a negative impact on both the nation's citizenry and the corporation's customers.

“We believe the best way for countries to promote the security and privacy interests of their citizens, while also respecting the sovereignty of other nations, is to ensure that surveillance is targeted, lawful, proportionate, necessary, jurisdictionally bounded, and transparent. These principles reflect the perspective of global companies that offer borderless technologies to billions of people around the globe. The actions the U.K. Government takes here could have far reaching implications – for our customers, for your own citizens, and for the future of the global technology industry,” the companies wrote.

The five companies belong to a larger group, the two-year-old Reform Government Surveillance (RGS) coalition that is fighting similar legislation in the United States. The RGS website lists Apple, AOL, Dropbox, Evernote and LinkedIn as members, but these names were not included in the U.K. letter.

The group spelled out its misgivings stating the implementation of such a policy could undermine consumer trust of their products, a fear that any legislation passed by the U.K. could be duplicated in another country and making it difficult for companies to understand what is legal and what is not.

“An increasingly chaotic international legal system will leave companies in the impossible position of deciding whose laws to violate and could fuel data localization efforts,” the companies said.

The letter also strongly rejected any use of backdoors, forced decryption or any other technological method allowing government agencies to enter their products.

“The companies believe that encryption is a fundamental security tool, important to the security of the digital economy as well as crucial to ensuring the safety of web users worldwide,” the group wrote.

RGS itself in May 2105 wrote to the U.S. Senate encouraging it to pass the USA Freedom Act. However, it has not yet, as a group, confronted American legislators on the issues of encryption and backdoors.


U.S.Defense Secretary Ashton Cater Doesn't Believe in Encryption Backdoors

Secretary of Defense Ashton Carter came out against supporting encryption back-doors at a conference panel on Wednesday. At the RSA information security conference in San Francisco, Carter told a packed room that he supported strong encryption and thought back-door access to encrypted communication as unrealistic. During his talk on the Apple vs. FBI case, which ...

Encryption May Hurt Surveillance, but Internet Of Things Could Open New Doors

Tech companies and privacy advocates have been in a stalemate with government officials over how encrypted communication affects the ability of federal investigators to monitor terrorists and other criminals. A new study by Harvard's Berkman Center for Internet and Society convened experts from all sides to put the issue in context. The report concluded that ...

Microsoft, Google, Facebook to U.K.: Don’t weaken encryption

Microsoft, Google and Facebook are urging U.K. officials not to undermine encryption as they work on laws that would authorize forcing communications service providers to decrypt customer traffic. In a joint written submission to the U.K. Parliament the three U.S.-based companies lay down several areas of concern, which, if not addressed, they say could damage ...

Netherlands opposes backdoors, but encryption still under assault

The Dutch government has officially declared its opposition to any restrictions on the development or use of encryption products, even as Dutch lawmakers are weighing legislation that could mandate backdoor government access to encrypted communications. In a 4 January 2016 letter to the Dutch parliament, the head of the Ministry of Security and Justice, Ard ...